Salt Vs Chlorine: Which Is Better?
The two most popular cleaning systems for pools are salt water and chlorine. But which is better? Each system has its advantages and disadvantages that you’ll have to consider depending on your individual preferences.
Chlorine Pools
Chlorine is the more traditional and cost-effective option for pool cleaning systems. Store-bought chlorine is used to disinfect the water in the form of tablets, sticks, or liquid. Chlorine functions to kill and oxidize bacteria and germs and deter algae. You’ll have to add chlorine to your pool weekly and anytime it rains (since your pool’s chlorine levels will be lower from fighting off contaminants).
The Advantages of Chlorine Pools
- Low initial investment, no generator required
- No added installation or maintenance of a generator
- No utility costs from running a generator
- Easier maintenance (although it requires frequent chemical balancing)
The Drawbacks to Chlorine Pools
- Chlorine pools can be irritating and harsh on the eyes, skin, and hair
- Can cause allergic reactions in some swimmers
- Requires regular maintenance, having to test the pool water and adjust chemicals weekly
- The cost of pool chemicals can add up, averaging around $600 for a summer season
- It can have a strong smell that may be unpleasant
Saltwater Pools
A saltwater pool is a gentle alternative to a chlorine pool. An electrolytic chlorine generator (ECG) separates salt in the pool water and generates chlorine using electrolysis. Electrolysis (for all the science nerds) is the chemical decomposition produced by passing an electric current through a liquid or solution containing ions. This means that a saltwater pool isn’t actually chlorine-free; it just makes lower levels of chloramines. Chloramines are a by-product of oxidation in the pool water and are the primary cause of eye and skin irritation and odour.
The Advantages of Saltwater Pools
- Lower levels of chloramines translate to less incidence of skin and eye irritation
- No chemical odour
- Lower ongoing investment (chlorine for summer runs around $120 for a summer season)
The Drawbacks to Saltwater Pools
- The salt can speed up the erosion of the pool
- The initial investment of a generator is on the higher side, costing up to $2,500
- Higher electricity bills from running the generator
- Higher repair costs as the generators are more complicated and require professionals to troubleshoot any issues
- Saltwater can ruin your landscaping and hardscaping
There are plenty of factors to consider when choosing the ideal pool cleaning system. If there is a dealbreaker like allergies or sensitive skin in your household, you might opt for the gentler saltwater system. Otherwise, it ultimately comes down to how much time and money you are willing to put into it.
If you need help deciding on your ideal pool cleaning system to suite your needs, feel free to reach out to us. Our team is always willing to help!
RELATED ARTICLES
Extend Your Pool’s Swimming Season
Swimming season doesn’t have to be so short! There are things you can do to extend the life of your pool and maximize the swimming season.
Top 10 Hottest Pool Toys & Accessories
Looking to make the most out of your pool this summer? We explore the hottest pool toys and accessories and they’re all affordable, durable, and safe!
Why We Love Small Pools (And You Should, Too!)
Smaller pools are a thing. We explore the upsides: small pools take up less space, require less maintenance, and cost less to operate and heat.
Salt Vs Chlorine: Which Is Better?
The two most popular cleaning systems for pools are salt water and chlorine. But which is better? We have a look at the pros and cons of each system.
What To Consider When Buying Your Swimpool
There are many different types and sizes of swim pools on the market. Narrow down your must-have features before purchasing the swim pool of your dreams!
The Ultimate Pool Liner Buying Guide
Pool liners generally last 8-10 years. We go over some important things to consider when replacing your liner like colour, pattern, texture, and thickness.
Pool Recovery After Harsh Winter Weather
Sudden drops in temperature, heavy snow, ice, and high winds can all contribute to pool damage.
How Covid-19 has impacted pool supplies
Getting your pool ready for the off-season every year can be a real pain. Let’s make it easy, while saving money. Here are all the amazing benefits of a safety cover.
Pool closing guide: how to properly winterize your pool
Getting your pool ready for the off-season every year can be a real pain. Let’s make it easy, while saving money. Here are all the amazing benefits of a safety cover.
Is a safety cover worth it?
Getting your pool ready for the off-season every year can be a real pain. Let’s make it easy, while saving money. Here are all the amazing benefits of a safety cover.
What caused the chlorine shortage of 2021?
Here are some of the best ways to reduce your chlorine usage and get the most out of your supply.
How do I decorate around my pool?
Where do you get started with decorating around your pool? We’ve got some expert tips to make your entire backyard shimmer and shine this summer.
The best pool equipment products for 2021
Looking to upgrade you pump, filter, heater, chlorination system or pool cleaner? We’ve put together our list of the the best equipment in 2021.
7 pool opening mistakes you can learn from
We’d rate pool opening as a moderately difficult DIY task. These pool opening mistakes are frustrating and can be costly. Read on to learn what not to do!
Yes, you can add steps to a pool. Here’s how.
We cover three of the most common inground pool stairs, from simple drop-in stairs to custom vinyl-over steel steps that completely transform your pool.
Compare pool liner colors in water
When you’re looking at a sample book or surfing the web it’s hard to compare pool liner colors in water—and it matters. This post gives a helping hand.
Pool makeover ideas
Bliss out at home this summer with these pool makeover ideas. The photos will spark your imagination and the write-ups will help you achieve the look.
Vinyl pool liner FAQs
How much does a new pool liner cost? What causes pool liner wrinkles? What’s the most popular liner colour? Here are 13 pool liner FAQs and the answers!
